Image of Chagrin Valley Times
May 24, 2007

Preserving history is a labor of love

By JOAN DEMIRJIAN

Patrick Cozzens' tools of the trade include a crowbar, a hammer and a power saw, all used in the fine art of salvaging historic architectural elements of old buildings.
He is at work now removing hand-hewn beams from a century house on the site where South Franklin Circle is being built in Bainbridge by Judson Retirement Community.

"You try not to break things," Mr. Cozzens said of the work that requires taking architectural elements apart, piece by piece. It is painstaking labor and involves much physical labor. "I want to remove them intact as much as possible," he said.
William Fehrenbach, project manager for South Franklin Circle project, said, "We were looking for a way to deal with the barns and the house, instead of sending them to a landfill." The structures were on the property purchased by Judson.
Mr. Cozzens went through the house and said he would take the windows, flooring, beams and woodwork. "We said, 'You're welcome to them,'" Mr. Fehrenbach said.

"We're thrilled it's not all going to a landfill," he said. "The house is in sad shape and was abandoned for many years," he said. "We' d like to see as much as possible be salvaged.

"It's more environmentally friendly," Mr. Fehrenbach said of Mr. Cozzens' removal and preservation of some of the architectural elements of the building.
There is also a stone foundation that Mr. Cozzens will remove to another location.
Mr. Cozzens, whose business is Western Reserve Classic Restoration and Architectural Salvage, just completed a restoration of his 1840s Greek Revival farmhouse in Auburn as well as a bank barn and outbuildings.

He said he had noticed the empty house on South Franklin Street and called the South Franklin Circle office in Chagrin Falls.

"I have an eye for old houses, and I knew it was post-and-beam construction," he said. He estimated its construction could date to 1830.

All the beams are hand-hewn, and they are still in good shape, Mr. Cozzens said.
The upright beams measure about 8-by-10 inches and the cross beams are 8-by-8. They are 22 feet to 24 feet long. "They came from some big trees," he said of the beams.

"The sills are not good," he said of the beams that sit on the foundation structure. The 3-by-8 flooring joists are poplar wood, and he has taken out many of the windows to be used in an old barn he owns in Auburn.
The railings and spindles of a stairway in the house were also salvageable, Mr. Cozzens said. The doors and all the stone for the foundation are worth saving as well, he said.

There were two "eye-brow" windows in the second floor of the structure, but they cannot be saved. However a fireplace mantel and the home's doors will be preserved.

Salvaged pieces will be used for his projects or he will sell them to others who restore old houses and barns. He will even save the old outside shutter hangers he has come across.

Mr. Cozzens plans to save one section of the house and rebuild it at his house in Auburn. He will number the pieces as he takes them down, making it easier to reconstruct them.

Susan Harris White, of Chagrin Falls, whose family owned the property,said it was known as the Gardner farm. Her great-grandmother, Mary Gardner, lived in the house.

Her grandfather had a horse farm on the site with a quarter-mile track to train the horses.

"I'm glad it's not going to a landfill or being burned," she said. "I'm happy someone is doing something good with it."

Most of the clearing is completed on the South Franklin Circle community site. Grading, utilities, filling and sewer, gas and electrical lines will be started this summer, early fall, Mr. Fehrenbach said.

They want to install foundations before winter, he said.

Like the house and barn, there have also been a couple of inquiries to move a house on Chagrin Road that is in the location of a road that will be constructed between Chagrin Road and South Franklin Street. It is still being investigated. We would rather do that than tear it down."

Used with permission of The Chagrin Valley Times.

For media inquiries about South Franklin Circle, please contact:
Rob Lucarelli
Public Relations Manager
(216) 791-2321
rlucarelli@judsonretirement.org